Tue, February 9, 2010
Logo
Public Opinion

Peru on the Brink

Peru must feel ignored. Three of its neighbors - Brazil, Chile, and Colombia are consistently praised by the Western press for their efficient economic management. The other two, Bolivia and Ecuador, attract attention for their ALBA initiative for regional integration. But in public relations terms, Peru lags behind, and few people are aware that this vibrant country of almost thirty million citizens is once again on the brink of massive political upheaval.

The Andean nation has had an unhappy recent history even by Latin American standards. A two decades long civil war between government forces and the Shining Path rebels left almost seventy thousand dead. The man who claims victory for the war, former President Alberto Fujimori, who served between 1990 and 2000, did not accomplish the feat with clean hands. He launched a “self-coup” in 1992, using the military to purge the national Congress and institutions hostile to him. Fujimori’s tenure was marked by corruption and state repression, and today he is serving a long prison sentence for his many human rights violations.

The post-Fujimori years have not been an era of national healing. In 2006, after a bitter election campaign, the former president Alan García narrowly defeated Ollanta Humala, a nationalist and ally of Hugo Chávez, to gain a second term in office. That García should have returned for another stay in the Casa de Pizarro seems to be almost a grand political joke, for as President from 1985-1990, his corrupt regime oversaw a massive increase in the national debt, poverty, and the devaluation of the currency by more than a million times. He too has been accused of gross abuses of human rights. In short, it was the uselessness of the García administration that created the conditions for the rise of Fujimori in the first place.

The García sequel is no better than the original. Last October, he accepted the resignation of his entire cabinet as a result of a corruption scandal. In June of this year, a government attempt to expropriate indigenous land in the Amazon for the purposes of oil exploration led to clashes that left more than fifty soldiers and civilians dead. Yet another prime minister resigned in the aftermath. And little has been done to end the malnutrition that strikes one in five Peruvian children.

As can be imagined, Alan García has the approval rating to match his dismal performance. In fact, the October poll conducted by Ipsos APOYO Opinión y Mercado for the leading daily El Comercio shows only 26% of Peruvians support the president. The firm, which laudably makes a great deal of information on the results available, openly admits that the survey was conducted only in urban areas. This of course means that the more than a quarter of the population that lives in rural areas must naturally be unrepresented in the poll.

In the 2006 election, García drew his decisive support from the Lima metropolitan area, gaining almost two-thirds of the vote there. He was heavily beaten in rural Peru, in some places losing to Humala by fifty or sixty points. This month, the poll for El Comercio shows that his approval in the capital has plummeted to just 34%. When we consider that the parts of the country that rejected him most resoundingly three years ago are precisely those left out of the poll, it would appear that to credit Garcia with 26% approval would in fact be significantly overstating his popularity. He is fortunate that the constitution spares him the humiliation of running in the next election.

Waiting in the wings is Ollanta Humala, who is looking forward to another try for the presidency in 2011. The former army officer, who came to national prominence after leading a military uprising against the Fujimori regime in 2000, has won the support of the indigenous poor with his Inca nationalism and plain talk (he recently called García and Fujimori “bastards” at a public meeting). With an increase in his percentage of the vote of only 3%, he will be Peru’s next president. But his radicalism terrifies Peru’s elite, which fears being drawn into the Bolivarian axis led by Venezuela.  And from the right the leading candidate is Keiko Fujimori, daughter of Alberto and former first lady, who campaigns on a platform of amnesty for her father and draws support from those who crave the firm leadership he offered.

When just last year only one in four Americans approved of George W. Bush, no one suggested that he might be toppled before his term expired. The U.S.’ strong traditions, institutions, and civil society prevented a collapse into ungovernability. In Peru, none of these things exist, and if Alan García’s administration survives until 2011, it will most likely because it is “the government that divides us least,” as another statesman said long ago. By 2011, at the latest, the presidency will be up for grabs, and Peru must find a new governing majority. This will not be an easy process.

Marc Lizoain

Marc is the co-founder of urtak.com, a public opinion website. He believes in DIY polling, and his main interests are politics, sports, and film. He was born in Toronto.

...
Read more about Marc Lizoain ->

Print This Post

Peruvian abroad... says:

This is an unfortunate, misinformed article.

Yes, Mr. Garcia has 30% of popularity, but Toledo governed for 5 years with less than 10% (AND he was clearly very indigenous looking...), and no, peruvians don't topple presidents in the streets..not even Fujimori managed that. Ollanta Humala has exactly the same amount of vote intention than there are poor in Peru...another 30%, who will vote for whomever will say everyone else is wronging them (and you cant blame them for that either). Peru has NEVER really had a popular president, at least not in the last 150 years (last popular one was in the 1850s). Peruvians don't like authority, period, but if you understood the country more, you would see there is no chance in hell peruvians are toppling a democratically elected President (Fujimori did a self coup...???..yes, we innovate constantly too, and he resigned by fax from Japan...???..and he was Japanese - case in point: peruvians don't give a llama's spit about Presidents). And this time around, no general or army officer will dare pull a coup (check out Humala's bro..in jail for 30 years). Highly unlikely at this point.

Garcia is not ideal, but peruvians made the right choice, though annoyed that there wasn't a better choice. In country that believes all authority to be inherently evil, what decent person wants to be the authority??

What you seem to fail to see is that Peru is actually the regions top performer, by far, and in every sense. Poverty has gone down from 56% percent to 34% in less than 5 years (IMF, and WB data..not Peruvian statistics), and extreme poverty is at 10% now. GDP Growth has averaged 7% over the last 5 years also. Education has taken an almost unheard of leap, with some of the most agressive programs around. And this year, it will grow 2% (I thought we raw materials exporters were supposed to have negative numbers...ahh, wait thats Chile, that US - EURO friendly country with "By Reason or by Force" as the national motto on their seal). This is isn't Alan Garcia, this is Peru, the peruvians are doing this, and its really worthy of admiration. Peruvians are fighting the Colombian and Mexican drug mafias trying to infiltrate the country and resuscitating old terrorist movements, the poverty and poor education eroding the country for years wasted on idiotic political regional agendas dictated from elsewhere, and a global economic crisis brought forth by brilliant high preforming new yorkers who ruled the world...so give us a break.

I have a feeling you went to see Macchu Picchu and got robbed or something and really don't like the place. No worries, just keep writing about Chile, Venezuela or Colombia. and let the peruvians do their thing on their own for once, which they know how to do very well. External forces have always screwed up Peru, and hopefully the nation wont lose focus and continue forward.

For transparency sake, I did work in the government 2 years ago, in the Finance Ministry, but I have been abroad for just over a year. I have no political affiliation to the current government, nor any desire to praise Alan Garcia, who you rightly mentioned was a corrupt economic catastrophe in the 80s. The man probably hasn't changed, but the country has, and so has the technical skill of the government middle management. Check's and Balances are in, and for good. I was there in he 80's, the 90's and up to one year ago. Best example is the recent corruption scandal you mention, this time it was very different...all of the involved are in jail(keeping the Fujimori group company I presume) and waiting for a trail (two President's friends included). I am also one of those from the "elite" who is white but has very real indian blood in them, and believe our people to be generous, hard working and overall joyful...if anything, peruvians on average are just to nice for their own good.

Do skip us next time, and write about Brazil or Chavez...

October 27, 2009, 7:32 pm


Get our Newsletter
  1. How to Bounce Back From a Job Loss
  2. Pinworms - You Have To Admire Them
  3. How Drug Companies Use Marketing to Mislead Physicians and Consumers
  4. Rush Limbaugh's Shockingly Stupid Argument About God and Climate Change
  5. Tim Tebow, Violence Against Women, and How Politics Can Ruin Sports
  6. Don't Mess With a Bunch of Pissed-Off Medievalists
  7. Why are CNN and HuffPo Eating Up Vice Magazine's Pathetic Reporting on Liberia?
  8. Groundhog Day: Sex and the Shadow
  9. Chris Paul as Gravity
  10. What's Being Done for Ethiopian - and Other - Domestic Workers in Lebanon